Important notice: Check out our Skepticism Panel at Gen Con Indy 2009! Four skeptics, two hours, one awesome seminar! Brought to you in association with Tom Foss and Wikinite! Register here!



11 December 2007

Action Review: "Paranormal State"

Short Version: A&E's new show "Paranormal State" is the worst, stupidest, most ridiculous fucking thing I have ever seen in any of the myriad forms of visual media. And I've seen Plan 9 From Outer Space and about 15 minutes of a Dane Cook stand-up special.

Long Version: I pray to the FSM that this show is, as one comma splicing Wikipedian claimed before a recent revision, that the show is, in fact, a Blair Witch style fiction. Beleving that there are people this fucking stupid out there who not only made it to college but then got a TV show all to themselves makes me just a tad homicidal.

The premise (hopefully fictional) is this: Penn State University has the country's "only collegiate paranormal research society," a claim I find completely dubious. Some douchebag (referred to hereafter as "Douchebag," because I can't be bothered to look up his name), the founder of said organization, only wants to help people who are haunted as he was haunted as a child. He is "searching for answers," which, as usual in the "Unknown and unsolved" crowd, means he's already found them.

Let me be completely candid: Douchebag and his buddies make Mario and Luigi from "Ghost Hunters" look like Neils Bohr and Alan Turing. Douchebag is an uber-serious, self-obsessed narcissist, their "methodologies" are more laughable than rods and orbs put together, and, to add insult to injury, they pray and spread around holy symbols like a fucking DnD cleric. See, they have what they call "Dead Time," where they just sit around and ask for ghosts to appear (always opened by a Christian prayer). It happens around 3AM, which is apparently "The height of activity in the supernatural realm," or something equally vacuous and made-up along those lines.

The show is basically Douchebag talking himself and his club up, an "investigation" that's like a gauntlet of biases and fallacies, and some Dead Time before they leave, all interspersed with "Director's Logs," essentially narration by Douchebag run through an audio filter so it sounds like it's coming from and old Victrola. Maybe that's "dramatic" or something.

The first episode I watched tonight involved an 8-year-old boy who was seeing "dark mists" and had an imaginary friend named "Timmy." He was so scared that he couldn't sleep! The child was also suffering from fairly obvious mental problems; he spoke poorly with an odd cadence, displayed a limited vocabulary, and never looked anyone in the eye.

So, rather than (a) buy a nightlight, (b) tell the kid that he's imagining things and if he doesn't go to sleep he can't play with his toys for a week, or (c) take the kid in for a psychological evaluation (the "dark mists" sound like a possible hallucination), the parents call Douchebag and the Undergrad Drool Patrol to find the ghosts and get rid of them. That's sure responsible of them.

Douchebag, remember, just wants to help people who are being haunted, and he sees some of himself in the boy. Factor in, now, the coincidence that "the body of a former resident in the house named Timothy" was found in teh woods behind the property, and you have a wodnerful ghost yarn. So Douchebag tracks down a picture of this former resident, shows it to the haunted child, and the following exchange ensues:

Douchebag: Your friend Timmy is in this picture.
Kid: He is?
Douchebag: Yes. [points to a person in the photo] This one.
Kid: This one?
Douchebag: Yes.
Kid: Yeah! It is him!

And this is taken as reliable testimony. "He recognized his friend, see!?"

Did I mention that the parents have seen no apparitions whatsoever? That they're simply believing the claims of an 8-year-old who seems to have mental problems?

The second episode that played last night involved some random haunted house. The real star of that episode wasn't the house, it was Douchebag and the demon that is haunting him. See, he's been having dreams of this name for the past week, and he's felt an evil presence. Everytime he mentioned "the name", there would be a cut to a rapidfire animation of evil-looking letters switching places in "the name" (it was "Belial;" DnD has taught me a few things) before going back to Douchebag.

After investigating the house, they brought in "One of the world's only real demonologists" to have a look around and spend Dead Time with them. She, a decrepit old woman with an underbite and jowls that frightened my girlfriend, flipped when Douchebag told her about the demon and "the name." She sensed a dark, evil presence. So they, as I said, went around blessing the place with holy water and (Christian) prayers, all the while hanging handwritten holy symbols above doors and hallways and trying to command and control the demon using its True Name (I shit you not). Then they contacted a priest, who apparently came in later and blessed the house. One of the inhabitants felt a "protective energy" after the blessing and attributed survival of a subsequent fire to said "protective energy."

Of course, Douchebag is still being tormented by his demon, and that's where they'll start off next week with Douchebag warning "It's like literally fighting a battle of good against evil."

This show made me want to punch people in the face repeatedly, like Hartigan did to the Yellow Bastard in Sin City. This show was so utterly useless that I'm on the brink of suicide. And you know what the worst part is?

They never even saw or heard anything that they attributed to a ghost!

They just sat around talking about what they "felt" was present for half a damn hour! No orbs, no EVP, nothing that even pretended at being physical evidence. Just talk. Inane, stupid, silly fucking pointless babble.

That'll sure convince us skeptics.

So, in conclusion, "Paranormal State" is a bigger waste of airtime than Celebrity Boxing. It is on the bottommost rung of television quality; it mixes entirely ignorant, utterly credulous paranormal melodrama with irritating Christian presumption.

Wikipedia lists it as a "docu-drama," which gives me hope that it might actually be fictional. Even if it is, though, it is ludicrous and irresponsible of A&E to market it as real. Aren't people stupid enough already without this dreck all over television?

Please, I'm begging you, dear readers, somebody leave a comment telling me truthfully (and with evidence) that this show is not, in fact, real, that it is only actors pretending to be the biggest morons in America. Please? Somebody?

43 comments:

Tom Foss said...

I'd like to tell you that it's not real, Akusai, I really would. I'd love to say that people aren't actually this retarded. But, as a skeptic, my primary goal is to find and spread the truth, which seems to be that people at big-name schools can be big-league dumb assholes.

And the only reason I know this is because someone called into the Atheist Experience show on Sunday from Penn State's atheist club, asking what the hosts thought would be the best way to counter this nationally-broadcast idiocy.

So, if there's a silver lining, it's that there's at least one group at Penn State actively campaigning to show what terrible douchebags this show employs.

Ron said...

I couldn't agree more with the assessment of this miserable, idiotic, goofy and vacuous waste of time. It pandered to the most uncritical and ignorant demographic (huge and growing audience I might add), and was a black eye to serious paranormal research. As a believer in what is often (mis)labeled as the "paranormal," I have to say that the only thing paranormal about "Paranormal State" is how many idiots will accept it at face value and gorge themselves on this tripe.

Tom Foss said...

black eye to serious paranormal research

So, um...can you show us where to find some of this "serious" paranormal research? Because I've never seen it, outside of "Ghostbusters."

bosox123 said...

It was bad. It was REALLY bad. Throughout the entire show I kept asking myself why I continued to watch it. "Douchebag" is caught up in some fanasy world that he has created for himself and is using this as a way to plow some dorky freshman chicks. No doubt about it. It was so corny and hokey that I'm ashamed to admit to anyone that I sat through it all. A&E needs to pull the plug on this show immediately in order to save face.

Julie said...

"As a believer in what is often (mis)labeled as the 'paranormal...'"

And you lost your audience.

Greg said...

I had to scream into a pillow this show was such a complete mess. Looks like someone (you say Douchebag, I say Fuckhead) has spent a little too much time at Jesus Camp.
Who decided this guy was a warrior for God?
I kept checking the channel to make sure I wasn't watching a DayStar show by mistake.
I am a fan of Abbot and Costello of Ghosthunters and would like to believe that they are on the level when it comes to evidence, but the thing about P.S. is well, THEY HAVE NO EVIDENCE. I'm supposed to believe the jesus freak and the old woman who called Carol Ann to come to the light.
Does A&E think we're really this stupid?

Bryan said...

By the way. The crusty old lady that they brought in for episode two was Lorraine Warren. As of fan of this paranormal shit, I'll tell you this: She and her husband were responsible for perpetuating some of the biggest hoaxes in ghost story history, namely The Amitville Horror and The Smurl Haunting. Look her up. It's funny.

Bronze Dog said...

As a believer in what is often (mis)labeled as the "paranormal," I have to say that the only thing paranormal about "Paranormal State" is how many idiots will accept it at face value and gorge themselves on this tripe.

I think you're working backwards on the talk of labeling. If it doesn't pass scientific muster, it's paranormal.

The only legitimate paranormal research I've seen is coming from skeptics. All the people who believe in it love to be sloppy and lazy so that they can let in biases and alternative explanations.

Alan said...

I am a fan of the paranormal and do enjoy "Ghost Hunters," so I looked forward to this show.

After about 15 minutes, I turned it off and watched "Knocked Up" instead on my OnDemand on Comcast.

Douchebag loves himself, his voice, and the fact he has a left ear pierced. That, apparently, makes him feel dark and handsome. Too bad he is just a...well...douchebag.

I also HATE the fact the show has a Christian slant with the fucking prayers and rituals. They don't try to contact or investigate, they instigate and ban all spirits "good or evil". That kind of thought will get you nowhere in terms of finding Douchebag's answers he wants so badly.

I'll stick to Ghost Hunters.

Michelle said...

I'm convinced it's fictional.
I walked away from my couch (and TV) to look up the show just now because I was absolutely certain that the Mother in the second story was acting.

She was not crying at the table.

Michelle

Рэйчел *レイチェル* 雷切爾 * 雷切尔 said...

You know it's bad if a psychic thinks it's full of bull****

Ineeda Dermy said...

It's better then Ghost Hunters. That show is more like The Real World. As for the review, get the basics straight—you are way off.

Real or not, "douchbag" seems to have more brains then you. You sound like that ignorant fuck in my freshman philosophy seminar.

Ineeda Dermy said...

Here's evidence that this review blows. "Douchbag" never points to "Timmy." Even if he did, they would never have shown it in the broadcast. This review blows.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=mEV7rmR0WMg

Bronze Dog said...

Why don't you try, you know, making a point or counterpoint?

Why do you woos have to resort to baseless bashing? If you're going to criticize, do some actual criticism.

Nothing but mope, mope, mope.

Akusai said...

ineeda:

I haven't the time right now to watch the video, but if I made an error and remembered incorrectly, I apologize. I, however, fail to see how my misremembering a single detail of the show, one that hardly invalidates the "proof" from the child's interview, in any way entails

(A) I am unintelligent.
(B) Douchebag is more intelligent than me.
(C) Ghosts exist and are haunting the child in the video.
(D) The demon Belial is haunting a man I have nicknamed "Douchebag."
(E) Demons exist, period.
(F) "Paranormal State" is not the worst piece of shit to ever air on television.

On the other hand, I believe the following argument to be both valid and sound:

p1. People who lack critical thinking skills are fucktards.
p2. Ineeda Dermy lacks critical thinking skills.
c. Ineeda Dermy is a fucktard.

Any questions?

PS. The quote

Even if he did, they would never have shown it in the broadcast.

seems to demonstrate your belief that though the show might, in fact, be legit, those involved in making it are dishonest, unscrupulous liars who manipulate the video to make themselves look good.

If this is true, they really need a new editor.

Webs said...

So I saw the video Ineeda linked, and it did come off differently than Akusai stated in the post.

However, what really happened is just as much bullshit as what Akusai originally stated. The boy points to a random person in the picture and guy says, "That is your friend Timmy". The boy says, "Whoa, that is my friend Timmy."

In other words the boy just randomly points to the photo and has no idea why or to whom he was pointing. So... please explain to us how that is concrete proof Ineeda?

What a stupid fucking show! And Ineeda you owe me 2 minutes of my fucking life back for wasting my damn time showing you how you and douchebag were wrong.

Julie said...

"Douchbag" never points to "Timmy."

You're right, he doesn't. Akusai did get that part wrong. What he didn't get wrong was the tone and confidence the child had when identifying Timmy. He sounded very unsure, and his voice held a definite question when he said: "He is?" and "Hmm, that one?"

Only when Douchebag confirmed it did the child say: "Yeah, it IS him!" This is a classic example of confirmation bias.

Tim said...

I wonder if Bob Larson will turn up on this show given it's apparent Christian bias.

Razide said...

I was watching something on A&E recently, and during every break, they had a commercial for this show. I remember how awful and irritating those commercials were, so your review of the show comes as no surprise.

I took a class once at Penn State. Judging by the quality of the education I recieved, it doesn't surprise me that the college is associated with this show.

Phobrek said...

I just watched the first ep of this show, and then did a search for it on google. It took me through seven pages of hits to find anything that didn't dumbly embrace the show... this post! Anyway, your review is good fun. When you mentioned the bit about them leading the kid with the picture, you hit the nail on the head. When they first started getting pics of Timmy, I was thinking, well, this would be a good idea, to put together a bunch of these pictures - like 30 mugshots from the high school yearbook - and ask him if any of them looked familiar. Instead they give him that wedding pic, and at that point I'm groaning, though amused.

A better moment for me was when the cut to a commercial, from a shot of the camera on the sleeping kid suddenly being jarred and f'ed up. The idea being... wow! That's something... I wonder how they'll explain that when they come back.... And then it's back from commercials, it's never mentioned, and was plainly something they did for ye olde kewl effect.

But yeah, it was the religious shit that took it to a higher level (so to speak). As soon as Adam (the psych major) said that "whatever's in this room really doesn't want me reading the Bible," I thought that that was funny, seeing as how I didn't want him reading it either. And when they started getting religious, OMFG. Beautiful.

And lastly, at the end, they've decided that this poor kid has a "special gift" and that his parents will have to help him live with it as he grows up, and that "nothing can stop him from seeing dead people," I was thinking... they should get their asses sued for manipulating this kid and his family. Is he now going to grow up with self-delusions, embraced by the unwitting parents?

And isn't it odd that they never asked questions about how they moved to the house, and if they were leaving things behind - like a friend, or family - and that their son might be reacting badly to it? Or inquiring about any other changes or possible sources of stress? And it would have been easy for this kid to have learned about dead Timmy out in the woods, unless his parents kept him locked up inside their house this whole time....

Anyway, I can't wait to see the next episode. As long as you take it for what it is, I think this show's a laugh-riot!

Rotten Arsenal said...

Episode 2: The demon (Belial) is amused by Douchebag.
So am I. I wonder if it's for the same reason?

GDad said...

The company where I work has a business partner that is located down the hall from A&E's Atlanta office. That's the only exposure I've had to A&E. That's the only exposure I need to A&E.

Adam, the drummer said...

Holy fucking shit!

How could that kid NOT know that someone died in his house? I grew up in a neighborhood that had a few skeletons in the closet. The two most notable were...
1.) A 3 year old girl almost drowning in a swimming pool. The near drowning left her severely brain damaged and in a (to borrow from relatively recent news stories) "persistent vegetative state".

and...

2.) A truck driver living in the neighborhood returning home from a long haul to find his wife in the living room, having shot herself in the head with a shotgun.

The amazing this is that my parents, to this day (and I'm 27) have never discussed ANY such occurrences with me (except for the nearly drowned girl...tragic), yet I still know about them. I didn't see a headless ghost wandering around, I simply heard it from the other kids (and one adult) in the FuCkInG neighborhood!

I'll bet the second day in the house, some kid asked the child in question, "Do you know a guy named Timmy died in your house?"

Dammit, people piss me off.

tHeCoNmAn said...

On the plus side, I haven't had this much fun making fun of a show on TV, nor this much success with the jokes with the rest of the people watching in a long time. (Although its not much of a challenge, as this is the most ridiculous thing I've ever seen.) I'm glad D-bag read his Diablo (PC Game) background stories and decided to use one of the names he found! My favorite was the "possession" which consisted of a fat man sweating. Watching all the "clients" act out in an attempt to stay on TV was like watching supernatural Springer. Then of course every thing is ok after they get their placebo effect from the snake oil salesmen.


On a slightly more serious note, if this is actually real, this Douchebag is wildly irresponsible and may be ruining some of these kid's lives. I didn't see the main episode you described here, but deluding the family into thinking a child who clearly has special needs has some sort of supernatural gift, preventing him from getting help is awful. (Unethical, without saying, but frauds and conmen don't worry about such things.) The other one I saw (before the fat guy possession episode) consisted of douche and his fat lisping "psychic" telling a woman that they were being haunted because her teenage son was "sad". She just stared and nodded. I shudder to think how much Prozac she got some doctor to pump him up with as a result of that.

Oh, and my favorite part of the whole thing, the fat guy possession episode, where the married couple (who was having "problems" and began counseling thanks to douchebag) pretty much recounted light injuries consistent with a domestic dispute and blamed it on "Belial". The only "evidence" beyond that was a four year old girl saying she had a monster that went "grr", and their obviously insane attention-whoring "family friend" acting like the "demon" was attacking her so ridiculously that even douchebag called her out in the voiceover.

Sorry this was so rambling, I caught a 2 am rerun of this stuff for the first time and was like twitching that it even exists.

ochndwellr2 said...

A fictional experience or no? Well, I'd have to lean towards a fictional experience that the producers put out as real, but with clues to it's fakeness for the smart ones out there. I too noticed the name of demon as Belial...Belial is a demon..the deomon of lies and mistruths...and is also a demon from hebrew faiths...so like another blogger said, christian fixes probably wouldn't work on it...and as far as Lorraine Warren goes...I believe they know about her being full of crap and put her on because of that. I believe that if we all take a different approach to this show...and watch it for the pure laughter and entertainment value I believe it is actually made for, we may just get a kick out of it. Take the test...watch and see how many clues you can find.

belle said...

the only thing worse than this ass rape of a tv show is "psychic kids"

Erin said...

Anybody notice that the producers of Paranormal State also produced Laguna Beach? Coincidence? I think not. This is the most transparent show I have ever seen.

jmilechman said...

wow! for people who think the show is a joke you all seem to watch it often... I've have seen them disprove things on the show several times and maybe sometimes it seems as though they are reaching but they are helping families who have issues. If nothing else they are making someones life a little less stressful no matter how true or fictional the situation maybe... I think you guys are the douchebags!

Bronze Dog said...

Yeah, because telling people they live in a horror movie universe is sooooo comforting.

Do you go to mental institutions dressed up in an MIB suit to comfort the paranoid schizophrenics?

Wikinite said...

wow! for people who think the show is a joke you all seem to watch it often...

I'm not sure what your point is. Part of debunking crap-spewing shows is to actually watch them...

I've have seen them disprove things on the show several times and maybe sometimes it seems as though they are reaching but they are helping families who have issues.

I'm still not sure what your point is. Debunking one falsehood only to replace it with another does not legitimize the replacement. Besides, I would assume in these cases that they debunk the specific instance but still keep the same bs framework. That is hardly debunking.

If nothing else they are making someones life a little less stressful no matter how true or fictional the situation maybe...

Except it's not just lying. It is creating a whole fantasy structure to predicate their lives around. That is harmful.


I think you guys are the douchebags!

It's true. I am often a douchebag, asshole, and an amoral man-whore. Unfortunately for you, that doesn't change the truth-value of anything said here.

Edwin said...

Dude you are sooo missing the point.
He makes MONEY. And myself being a professional magician and Con Man am fully behind teh idea that if people ar too stupid to keep their money then I'll take it from them.
In that vein, I am sure I can feel dark shaples things in anyones home and for a small fee keep them at bey, if not banish them completely.
I can't honestly say if ghosts ar ereal or not. there is no concrete evidence either way. have these guys seen things? well I am sure with some help from teh crew and over eager clients many things will manifest (amazinmgly it's always just off camera, or just out of site)
As a magician I have not seen anything that I can't recreate (though that does not disprove anything) But I have been party to personal events that defy explination or exposure. I am a firm waffling ghost agnostic. But the only bigger psychic fraud I know of tht prick John Edwards.
But i believe enough to make money off of the misty little bastards.

Akusai said...

So what you're saying is that you're a total asshole who uses people for his own ends?

Thanks for playing, but you lose, dickhead.

jean jacques rousseau said...

This is the funniest most brilliant review I have ever read. Seriously. I was laughing until I was crying.

Phenomic said...

okay i want to be frank first of all this fucking review is completely biased and cutting down others beliefs and second of all you have no evidence to justify the occurences people are having are not those of actual earth boud spirits or ghosts third of all, out of all the shit you pulled out of your ass the fact that he bases his ghostly accusations on christian belief, 3:00 am is counted as the mockery of christ not the hieght of paranormal activity in which case the malevolent activity is presumably most active whether i believe this or not is my choice it depends on your faith on the matter, now then to say that he is christian is true because he is, but the ridiculous rant you went on is biased against christians, and to consider he only bases his assumtions on the religion is biased you need to figure out that if spirits were actually real then why do they go centuries back in all religions not just christianity but ALL RELIGIONS including those that date before christianity for example greek egyptian native american chinese japanese and including but not limited to satanism....

now to say that his view is biased may be true but to think that he is limited to the intellegence of a cleric is simply preposterous.... and as for DND (so called "cool" game of the 80's or 90's or what ever) is fucking stupid you cannot say that anything in dugeons and dragons has any tie to that of paranormal research either your a fucking retard or you have not studied enough in the paranormal to make such a review on this television program (if it's real or not it's not up to me to decide what i believe is my choice not yours, it's not my place to suggest this so called "biased" television program is real or not it's in what you believe) so really until you can accept the fact that your fucking review is biased you will never have your true great review your thoughts will be as intellegent as those who agree with your so called unbiased legitimate thought on your homicidal mind which i highly doubt is really homicidal rather just angry that douchebag made it to college and you didn't so until then keep it to yourself because the really intellegent people want to see a real review not some indiginified glory wanters rant.....

p.s. the host is a douche not wanting to defend him of that

Akusai said...

You, sir, are a moron.

Thanks for dropping by, though.

Bronze Dog said...

Wow. The doggerel is dense with this troll.

First off, the truth doesn't care who it offends. We live in the free world, where NOTHING is beyond criticism. Or at least, that's how it's supposed to go.

Second, shifting the burden of proof. There's no evidence of spirits. It's not up to us to prove something doesn't exist: It's up to the people who believe in something to prove it. Of course, more than that, they have to define the concept so that it's not convenient gibberish the incurious like you can use to handwave away the need to investigate.

Third, popularity of a concept is not evidence of its truth. Thank you for reaffirming my perception of woo being associated with conformist mentalities.

4 Peeps said...

Oh Thank God someone took the time to call this pos of a show out!!! I do admit, I watch it..desperate for "Douchebag" to redeem himself in someway. To be fair, they truly believe that what they are doing is making a difference as long as it is not too far of a drive from the dorms. How far will you go "Douchebag" really how far?
There has NEVER been anything to make me believe that there was something there except a boom/sound guy grunt behind a door turning a fucking knob.
What a joke

eliangonzalez said...

The only demon haunting "Douchebag" is the Love That Dare Not Speak Its Name.

RICKY said...

March 23, 2009

I don't watch this show regularly, but have caught a few episodes. (unfortunately) I have got to say that this latest episode has got to be be the most pathetic one yet. They basically reinacted the movie The Exorcist. (only with very bad acting)the mother of the possessed girl even had the same hairstyle and color as the mom from The Exorcist. (This crap should be on the comedy channel) I personally have been involved with paranormal research for many years, and do participate in investigations, and this show is an insult to people who are legitimately seeking an answer to the question of weather or not ghosts exist, and why. No matter how bored I get I wont make the mistake of wasting my time watching this show again. And I will pray that it gets cancelled soon.

King of Ferrets said...

Uhhh, all the evidence is against ghosts. It's pretty much a settled question on the ghost existence; the answer is no.

Joshua said...

One thing I noticed about the main douchebag on the show, is that he seems to think he is Keanu Reeves' character from the movie Constantine. He even speaks in a droning tone of voice that is present in almost every character played by Reeves. Douchebag is living in a fantasy world where he is Constantine, "battling" against "demons" in a war between good and evil that simply doesn't exist. The amount of gullible retards that play into this "ghost hunter" fantasy bullshit makes me feel sad for humanity.

Shaine said...

My wife loves any show that has to do with the "paranormal", and I complain every time she watches 'Paranormal State'. An episode is airing on the TV in our bedroom as we speak, though I haven't been following it.

I found this by searching google for "Paranormal State Bullshit" - seriously. After reading a few other sites, I just had to comment here.

When I was four years of age, I had what I believed to be a paranormal experience. At the time, I lived in a very rural part of Virginia in an extremely large barn that was converted to attached 2-story homes (much like townhomes but not quite).

One night, I saw what looked like three civil war soldiers and a woman come out of the wall on the left side of my bedroom (right if looking from the entryway), cross the room at the foot of the bed while staring at me, then disappear.

I have sworn my entire life that, although I do not obsess over the paranormal, I believe at least in the existence of such things.

However, I have told my wife that, just from the sheer crap contained within this show, I've begun to question the validity of my own experience - one I've carried the memory of for 23 years. It's ironic that, despite my alleged incident, this show is actually making me MORE of a skeptic.

Anyway, that's my two cents.

Akusai said...

Even more ironic, Shaine (at least in my opinion), is that despite the intent of the show, it is making you more of a skeptic.

I think that questioning one's own experience is one of the most important parts of critical thinking in general. In order to get a good handle on what's really going on outside our heads, we have to recognize our own cognitive shortcomings and biases and own up to just how fallible we really are.

I think it's good that you're starting to question what, until now, galvanized your weak belief in the supernatural. Four-year-olds, after all, are a bit more susceptible to cognitive bias than adults, and such a memory, however vivid, doesn't constitute a solid foundation for belief.

I don't know about you, but my opinion is that the other paranormal investigation shows are just shades of Paranormal State. At their core, they all display the same ignorance, the same self-obsession, and the same lack of connection with reality. Some of them are just a lot slicker about it, and a lot less The Exorcist.